Skip to main content

Summary: A substantial modification of machinery, as defined in Machinery Regulation (EU) 2023/1230, is a change made by physical or digital means after the machinery has been placed on the market or put into service, which was not foreseen by the manufacturer and which affects safety by creating a new hazard or increasing an existing risk. The person who makes such a change takes on the obligations of the manufacturer.

Adding a new function to machinery in use, increasing its capacity or changing its control system can, in some cases, turn it into “new machinery” in legal terms. The person who made the change is then considered the manufacturer and takes on all obligations of the CE conformity process. Regulation (EU) 2023/1230 addresses this for the first time with an explicit definition.

The Current Situation: Directive 2006/42/EC

The Machinery Directive contains no definition of “substantial modification”. In practice, the European Commission’s Guide to application of the Machinery Directive and the Blue Guide are followed: interventions that significantly change the original performance, purpose or type of the machinery and that affect the risk assessment may lead to the machinery being treated as a new product. Because there is no definition, the boundary is often disputed.

The Definition in Regulation (EU) 2023/1230

Under the Regulation, a substantial modification is a modification of machinery, by physical or digital means, after it has been placed on the market or put into service, that is not foreseen or planned by the manufacturer and that affects safety by creating a new hazard or increasing an existing risk. To be substantial, the change must also require one of the following:

  • the addition of guards or protective devices that require the existing safety control system to be modified, or
  • the adoption of additional protective measures to ensure stability or mechanical strength.

The words “by digital means” matter: not only mechanical interventions, but also software updates and changes to control system parameters can amount to a substantial modification.

Who Is Considered the Manufacturer?

Retrofit of an older press with a new control cabinet

Under the Regulation, the natural or legal person who carries out a substantial modification is considered a manufacturer and is subject to the manufacturer’s obligations. Where the modification affects only part of an assembly of machinery (a line), the obligations are limited to the part affected. This person may be the company using the machine in its own plant or a firm carrying out a retrofit.

Examples: Likely Substantial and Not Substantial

Usually not a substantial modification May be a substantial modification
Replacement with spare parts of the same specification Increasing speed, force or capacity
Maintenance and repair foreseen by the manufacturer Changing the intended use of the machinery
Improvements that keep or raise the safety level without creating a new hazard Changing the control system or safety software
Fitting options foreseen in the manufacturer’s instructions Adding automatic feeding or a robot to a manually fed machine

Each case must be handled through its own risk assessment; the table is only a guide.

What Is Required After a Substantial Modification?

Engineer performing a risk assessment on modified machinery
  • A risk assessment is carried out for the part affected by the modification, and the relevant essential health and safety requirements are met.
  • The technical documentation is compiled or updated.
  • The conformity assessment procedure is applied; if the machinery falls under Annex IV of the Directive (Annex I of the new Regulation), notified body involvement may be required.
  • The declaration of conformity is drawn up, and the CE marking and manufacturer details are affixed.

Responsibility for Non-Substantial Changes

Even when a change is not substantial, machinery in use remains subject to occupational health and safety legislation, in the EU under the Work Equipment Directive 2009/104/EC as transposed nationally. The employer must assess and document that the equipment is safe after the change.

TESTPLUS carries out conformity assessment as a notified body (NB 2908) for machinery. For Annex IV machinery, see our Machinery CE Certification page, and for the other changes in the new Regulation, our article on Machinery Regulation (EU) 2023/1230.

Substantial Modification: Frequently Asked Questions

Is every software update a substantial modification?

No. A software or hardware change is a substantial modification only if it creates a new hazard or increases an existing risk not foreseen by the manufacturer, and as a result requires guards or protective devices that change the existing safety control system, or additional protective measures for stability or mechanical strength. The answer is determined by the risk assessment.

What are the obligations of the person who makes a substantial modification?

That person fulfils the manufacturer’s obligations for the part affected by the modification, or for the whole machine if the whole machine is affected: risk assessment, technical documentation, the appropriate conformity assessment procedure, the EU declaration of conformity and the CE marking. If the modified machinery is in a category listed in Annex I, notified body involvement may be required.

Official Sources